Did Parents in Previous Generations Do a Better Job of Faith Retention?

On October 13th I did a seminar for Thrive, one of the ministries of the Christian Reformed Church, on Keeping Kids Christian. I had a great time and the video of the seminar is now public.

Keeping Kids Christian has the great dechurching in its background: there has been an absolutely massive number of kids who grew up in Christian homes who now have no Christian faith or practice, and this dechurching is overwhelmingly driven by Gen X and Millennials coming of age in the 90s and early 2000s. There’s been a lot of ink spilled to explain why this happened, with the general consensus being something like “The social pressure to be Christian contra godless communism dissipated with the end of the Cold War, and then the introduction of the internet freed people to settle on different (non)approaches to religion”. The argument of my book is that dechurching is not inevitable, but that there are things parents can do to form their kids for lifelong faith retention. The number one factor in faith retention is the parent-child relationship, particularly parenting style.

In 1967 Psychologist Diana Baumrind defined three parenting styles: authoritative, authoritarian, and permissive. A fourth was style was identified 1983, “uninvolved”, which is sometimes called “passive”. I didn’t address this history in Keeping Kids Christian, but these approach to parenting styles has dominated the field since Baumrind’s work. Sociologists have known for decades that parental influence is that greatest factor in faith retention; Amy Adamczyk and Christian Smith in Handing Down the Faith asked what effect each parenting style has on faith retention (it’s authoritative). Keeping Kids Christian is about how to apply that to the ministry of the church

The reasonable question I have gotten since the book was published is “Were the parents of Gen Xers and Millennials less authoritarian/permissive than previous generations? And is that why the great dechurching occurred?” In other words, are there changes in parenting styles across generations that can explain the great dechurching?

The short answer is that there is no study that has attempted to answer this question.

The slightly longer answer is that there is a scarcity of any data on the shift in parenting styles at all. Part of the reason for this is because such studies would have to be retrospective: asking Silent/Boomer parents and Gen X/Millennial adult children their perceived of how they parented/were raised, but years after the fact. There was a study done in 2007 where parents generally thought they were more relaxed and warm in their parenting style compared to their own parents, but memories and self-perception are often fuzzy and self-congratulatory. There was a shift throughout the 20th century from parent-centered, institutional and regimented childhoods with an emphasis on obedience to more child-centered, expressive parenting models that emphasized independence. And while that seems to line up with a movement from authoritarian to permissive parenting, that cultural movement doesn’t address questions of warmth and love, which are key elements of authoritative parenting. There is one 2020 study focused on three generations of Spanish families, and it found that there was a consistent movement away from strictness towards relaxed and warm parenting, but is neither specific (parenting styles, faith retention) nor general (just one study of one smaller group) enough to draw conclusions.

Strict and regimented are not the same as harsh, and child-centered and expressive is not the same as permissive or passive. The shifts in the 20th century that preceded the great dechurching also don’t take into account the rise of extreme helicopter parenting and subsequent programming every moment of children’s lives in the 21st century, much less gentle parenting. Parents are spending more time with their kids now than they did in the mid-to-late 20th century, but time spent does not describe the quality and style of the time spent. Parents are more involved, but that’s not the same as firm and warm.

It would be easy to say that Silents/Boomers were either too harsh or too permissive compared to their own parents, and that’s what led to the great dechurching. But the data is not there. What is far more likely is that there is giant mish-mash of parenting styles across generations, and what changed was the end of the Cold War with the rise of the internet (among other factors in the 1990s-2000s). There was a social Christian default that could absorb poor parenting styles, and when that default was disrupted, parenting styles become far more critical for lifelong faith retention. Which is all the more reason to take seriously and proactively now the loving responsibility of authoritative parenting.